Ok y'all. A bunch of you requested the recipe for Pumpkin Sandwich Cookies, so here goes. Sorry I don't have photos to go with this post, you'll just have to imagine.
Pumpkin Sandwich Cookies
Oven at 375*
Yield: approximately 25 sandwich cookies.
1 cup sugar
1 c cooked pureed pumpkin (or canned pumpkin)
1/2 cup shortening
Blend together. Then stop mixer to add:
2 cups flour
1 tsp baking powder
1 tsp baking soda
1 tsp cinnamon
You can add chocolate chips, raisins, and/or nuts if desired.
Mix together. The batter will be a bit on the thick side. That is a good thing.
Bake for 8-10 min on greased cookie sheet.
These cookies are kind of hard to tell when they are done. They will get that "golden brown" look, but it is hard to see because they are already kinda dark cookies. In my oven, they take a full 10 min.
For making the sandwich cookies, you won't want to "drop" them onto the sheet. They turn out too fluffy, and you'll end up with pumpkin cookie balls (fun, but kinda dangerous in the wrong hands). So, what I do to get around that problem is to fill a ziplock freezer bag (the freezer bags are a little sturdier and won't be so prone to bursting; I'm speaking from experience here) halfway full of the batter. Yes, the batter is supposed to be a bit on the thick side. Then seal the bag, cut a corner off the bag, and make pretty little circle patties on your cookie sheet. They can be fairly close together, the cookies don't "grow" much at all. I like my circles to be roughly 2" in diameter and about 1/2" thick, though the thinner you make them the faster they bake, and the more cookies you'll get.
On a side note. I have tried using oil to replace the shortening and the cookies ended up really sticky once they were baked off. They would stick to each other, our hands, the ziplock bags, everything. So use shortening and you'll get lovely cookies each and every time.
Once you have all your cookies baked off, make the filling. Which just happens to be cream cheese frosting.
8 oz cream cheese at room temperature
powdered sugar
Blend well until you have a thick frosting.
Put frosting in freezer ziplock bag (sound familiar?). Cut corner off. Frost the underside of one cookie and stick it to the underside of a second cookie. Eat first one, then make more.
There you have it! Pumpkin Sandwich Cookies.
3 years ago











